This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 4 minute read

Supporting persistent non-attenders from becoming NEET: Moving from confusion to legal clarity

This article forms part of Stone King's ongoing thought leadership series examining the recommendations and implications of the Milburn Report for education, workforce development and social mobility for young people.

Thousands of children around the country are not attending school. These are not the children who will be captured by the new children not in school register the government is introducing, but children who remain on their school roll but do not attend. The reasons for such high levels of non-attendance are multiple and complex, both for the individual child concerned and at a societal level. With the recent publication of the Milburn report, the understandable focus is supporting young people back into ‘education, employment or training’. But getting children back into education at an earlier stage, before they become ‘NEET’, would support such a priority.   

Whilst the individual circumstances of each case will differ, there are some fundamental underlying legal obligations for parents, schools and local authorities in relation to attendance. Here I consider what steps their schools and local authorities must take to ensure pupils’ visibility and safety while ‘at home’, and to secure their ‘education’ while they are not attending.

If a child is on the roll of a school, they cannot simply be deleted if they stop attending. Both the school and the local authority (LA) have obligations to address non-attendance and should work together to do so. Where there are no reasonable grounds to believe that the child will return, the school and LA must first take into account “any reasonable steps” they can take to secure the child’s attendance. And both the school and LA will continue to have safeguarding responsibilities towards them; they must work together to assure themselves, and ensure, the safety of that child. This involves sharing information about that child, and the family and wider context that shapes their life.

When a child stops attending, it is for the school to establish the reason for their absence and to record it using the appropriate code (there are numerous codes but these can be categorised broadly as ‘authorised’ or ‘unauthorised’). Separately, parents have a duty to ‘cause’ their child to be educated (an odd, but statutory turn of phrase); correlative to the child's right to be educated. If a parent is failing to fulfil that duty, the LA may take enforcement action against them. 

The education that a parent is to ‘cause’ their child to receive should be ‘efficient’, ‘full time’ and ‘suitable' to their 'age, ability, aptitude’ and any ‘special educational needs’ (SEN) they may have.   Whilst some parents may be supportive of their child not attending school, for example because they do not consider it suitable for their child's SEN, in other situations parents may be struggling to get their child into school for a variety of reasons. The phrase ‘emotionally based school avoidance’ (EBSA) is increasingly used to describe a significant number of children who may not have any medically diagnosed reason not to be in school but have become persistently absent. Decisions as to whether to ‘authorise’ such absence, or for it to be ‘unauthorised’ will be taken on a case by case basis, often putting schools in a very difficult position where they are being required to assess whether the child’s anxiety or reluctance to go to school constitutes a medical reason not to be in school.

How a child’s absence is categorised is important. Not only will it determine whether or not enforcement action could be taken against the parent by the LA, but it will also determine the steps that should be taken to educate and support the child while absent. The Department for Education has issued guidance to schools that they must notify their LA if they have reasonable grounds to believe that a pupil will miss 15 days (consecutive or cumulative) because they are unwell. This notification should trigger the LA's statutory obligation to arrange ‘suitable’ education for that child, which is to be full-time unless the child's needs are such that they can only manage part-time education (an equivalent obligation kicks in from the sixth day of a child's suspension - to be provided by the school). However, when is this obligation triggered when a child's absence is not due to illness? That the LA is statutorily obliged to provide such education for children who may not ‘otherwise’ attend school is clear, but not when.  

Given this lack of clarity, there remain significant numbers of children for whose parents an enforcement order would be inappropriate, but the reason for their absence has no clear medical evidence. Because they remain on the school roll, they are not categorised as ‘children missing education’ (triggering home education checks, such as they are), but conflict arises between schools and LAs as to whether such children fall into the category for whom the responsibility falls on the LA to step in and arrange their education. To my mind, the bar for entering that category is low: it includes children who ‘may not for any period’ receive education unless an LA were to provide it. But the ‘unless’ of course is what schools and LAs disagree over; if a school is providing (through tutoring or arranging alternative provision), then the obligation on the LA is not triggered. For children who have an EHCP, however, the bar is even lower insofar as the statutory obligation on LAs (to secure the special educational provision (SEP) contained in their EHCP) does not fall away if they are not attending school. For schools, arguably it does: they are only ever obliged to ‘use their best endeavours’ to secure that SEP, and if a child stops attending school, can a school continue to provide what a child needs to come to school to receive?

Improving school attendance is complex, but essential if we are going to respect children’s rights to education and take steps to prevent them falling into a growing category of young people who are NEET. Children who are not attending school are some of the most vulnerable in our society, but the current lack of legal clarity results in wrangling over who should be taking responsibility (financial and practical) to support them, rather than immediate and clear pathways of support opening up at an early stage so that they can, as soon as possible, start once again receiving ‘suitable’ education. 

Around a third of young people who are persistently absent in Years 10 and 11 in England go on to be Neet, compared with 10% of those who are not persistently absent.

Tags

academies and mats, faith schools, further education, state-funded schools, public policy, send, milburnreport