This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 2 minute read

'Reasonable adjustments': what is reasonable, what is not

The Department for Education is producing guidance for schools* on what may be considered to be ‘reasonable’ or ‘unreasonable’ adjustments under the Equality Act. This is to be welcomed. *Whilst press coverage to date refers to the guidance being for schools, it is expected that it will also apply to colleges given their parallel duties in relation to making reasonable adjustments for students.

As education lawyers, too often we see ‘wish lists’ of ‘reasonable adjustments’ submitted by or on behalf of children and young people. Framing a request as such carries a presumption of reasonableness, but it is important to keep in mind that the duty to make adjustments only arises in certain circumstances and what is ‘reasonable’ always depends upon context. So, what may be reasonable in one school or college may not actually be reasonable in another.

It is helpful to go back to the actual wording of the Equality Act, which does not contain the presumption that all adjustments requested for a disabled student will be reasonable. Specifically, the duty in section 20 is ‘to take such steps as it is reasonable to have to take’ to avoid putting a disabled person at a substantial disadvantage due to the school or college’s way of doing things. ‘Reasonable’ will always require a careful assessment of the circumstances, nature of the disadvantage and feasibility of avoiding it. However, it is essential to read section 20 as amended by Schedule 13 of the Equality Act in relation to how the duty applies to schools (and other educational settings including colleges). That is, where (to paraphrase) ‘some practice’ or lack of some support substantially disadvantages particular groups of disabled students (e.g. those who have bladder complaints) in comparison with their non-disabled peers, schools and colleges are obliged to take steps that are reasonable to avoid that disadvantage. So, in addition to context being important, what is reasonable is also to be determined by what would be considered reasonable for the school or college to take for that particular group of disabled students (e.g. those who have bladder complaints).

Accordingly, any ‘wish list’ can only be judged in relation to what would be reasonable for the school or college to take for the whole group of disabled students, not the individual. And again, if certain steps were considered reasonable at one setting (e.g. a child's primary school), that does not necessarily mean that they will automatically be reasonable at another. Finally, it goes without saying that if a school or college considers a step to be ‘unreasonable’, continuing to refer to it as a ‘reasonable adjustment’ is not helpful.

It is to be hoped that the new guidance provides useful clarification on what can be a contentious area. At the time of writing, the timing of publication is not known, but it would be logical for it to appear along with key SEND reform documentation such as the Education for All Bill and National Inclusion Standards, which are now not expected before the new year. 

In the meantime, should you require advice on related matters, please contact our Education team, who will be happy to assist.

The Department for Education has set out examples of what could be seen as reasonable and unreasonable adjustments that schools could make for pupils with special education needs

Tags

academies and mats, education, faith schools, further education, independent schools, state-funded schools, education training, education white paper, send